Buying a home wins hands down against renting today. Here’s why

Buying a home wins hands down against renting due to Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana and RERA laws


I have this running debate with my youngest client and perhaps, the most financially savvy. This client has spent a few years already as a marketing professional in a software company in Bangalore and got married recently.

Unlike many fellow professionals, he had sought out my services almost as soon as he started his working career. The family has all the required insurance policies and even save a tidy sum every month in a portfolio of mutual funds balanced between their near term and long-term goals. We agree on everything except this: whether they should buy a house or should they rent it? He used to stay in a rented apartment before marriage and since he really liked the area, even after marriage, they continue to stay there. However, despite lucrative several offers to buy an apartment in the same area, he refuses to do so.| Latest economy news

His argument is based on an excel sheets in which he has analysed the rent versus buy decision fully. On rent, he has taken into account reasonable assumptions on increases in rent over the years, including the rise due to increase in the market value of the property, the cost of security deposits, the brokerage and other transaction costs that he will have to pay every time he renews a lease and above all, even moving expenses every few years.

On the buy side, he has taken into account the fact that he will be able to get a home loan and get tax benefits on the loan repayments, besides accounting for maintenance and society charges.|economy today

He has worked out both the numbers and has concluded that for the next 30 years, the property would have to appreciate at around 15 per cent a year to break even with renting. Otherwise, he would be much better off just renting till he retires in 30 years and use the invested money to buy a senior citizen friendly home when he retires.

My argument with him has always been that any financial model completely ignores the softer and emotional aspects that too have a financial impact. He had major problems convincing his future wife’s parents that he wasn’t willing to buy a property despite having the means to do so. They did not believe him and thought he was fibbing about his income. The cost of defying a widely-held social convention is a recurring cost.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s